Re: [EVGRAY] Benefiting from the Evolution in Power Transistors or smoke saver

Database ID: 110792
2018-11-24T14:35:31-08:00

← View thread

Message-ID
In-Reply-To: <CAPYb0EFi74xVZ2jFd33Pz_c9_dQ75CPvQmox=cyCXmnV_gTYFw@mail.gmail.com>

Body

Bob,

I was talking to a designer of a switching RF amp the other day.  I
asked him if he tried the new SiC chips rather than the MOSFET he uses
for the output.  He said he had tried a bunch but they don't last.  I
looked at his favorite FET datasheet and between the gate and source is
a pair of counter facing series zeners build into the wafer. I asked did
you try putting similar on the board, no he said space was lacking.

So if anybody is losing the magic smoke I suggest they try the Zener
trick and Ole can likely tell us the proper name of this protection
topology rather than smoke saver.

On 11/24/2018 8:37 AM, Bob Paddock [email protected] [EVGRAY] wrote:
>  
>
> One of the other treads was discussing the destruction of MOSFETs,
> which motivated me to write these few posts, where I normally just
> lurk here.
>
> Related to my Magick Smoke post.
>
> Benefiting from the Evolution in Power Transistors, such as Gate
> Injection Transistors and Cascode Silicon Carbide Transistors.
>
> Gate Injection Transistor:
>
> https://www.mouser.com/applications/wide-bandgap-gan-transistor/
>
> "Panasonic PGA26E X-GaN Power Transistors
>
> Panasonic PGA26E07BA and PGA26E19BA X-GaN Power Transistors are 600V
> Gallium Nitride power devices based on Gate Injection Transistor (GiT)
> technology. PGA26E X-GaN power devices deliver Normally-Off operation
> with extremely high-speed switching characteristics and zero recovery
> loss.
>
> FEATURES
> Crystal growth of X-GaN on 6" silicon substrate
> 600V enhancement mode power switch
> Normally-Off operation with a single X-GaN device by proprietary Gate
> Injection Transistor (GIT) technology
> Extremely high-speed switching characteristics
> Zero recovery loss characteristics"
>
> See the GiT link:
> https://www.mouser.com/Panasonic/Semiconductors/Discrete-Semiconductors/Transistors/Newest-Products/_/N-ax1rp?P=1z13zdy
>
> See also, look for Panasonic:
> http://www.bodospower.com/restricted/downloads/bp_2014_07.pdf
> http://www.bodospower.com/restricted/downloads/bp_2017_02.pdf
> http://www.bodospower.com/restricted/downloads/bp_2017_05.pdf
> http://www.bodospower.com/pdf/bp_2018_07.pdf
>
> ----------------------------------------
>
> Cascode Silicon Carbide Transistors:
>
> "Benefiting from the Evolution in Power Transistors"
>
> and
>
> "A Novel Circuit Topology for Turning a ‘Normally On’ GaN Transistor
> into ‘Normally Off’ that Can be Driven by Popular Drivers":
>
> https://www.bodospower.com/restricted/downloads/bp_2018_06.pdf
>
> See http://unitedsic.com for related parts and applications notes such as:
>
> "Cascode Configuration Eases Challenges of Applying SiC JFETs"
> http://unitedsic.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/USCi_AN0004-Cascode-Configuration-Eases-Challenges-of-Applying-SiC-JFETs.pdf
>
> Order from:
> https://www.mouser.com/search/refine.aspx?N=4248705613
>
> -- 
> http://blog.softwaresafety.net/
> http://www.designer-iii.com/
> http://www.wearablesmartsensors.com/
>
>

References

<CAPYb0EFi74xVZ2jFd33Pz_c9_dQ75CPvQmox=cyCXmnV_gTYFw@mail.gmail.com>

Headers

Return-Path <[email protected]>
X-Sender [email protected]
X-Apparently-To [email protected]
X-Received (qmail 10999 invoked by uid 102); 24 Nov 2018 22:36:11 -0000
X-Received from unknown (HELO mtaq6.grp.bf1.yahoo.com) (10.198.29.79) by m8.grp.bf1.yahoo.com with SMTP; 24 Nov 2018 22:36:11 -0000
X-Received (qmail 28349 invoked from network); 24 Nov 2018 22:35:35 -0000
X-Received from unknown (HELO mta4004.groups.mail.ne1.yahoo.com) (10.218.140.75) by mtaq6.grp.bf1.yahoo.com with SMTP; 24 Nov 2018 22:35:35 -0000
X-Original-Return-Path <[email protected]>
X-Received-SPF pass (domain of gmail.com designates 209.85.210.172 as permitted sender)
X-YMailISG izwchbEWLDuFYfCXw5gDLpWdosdoJyZ9Z4mjERU_1G4G6Gge rvciec9DD5KzL6fsTxkVEoV1ZDy2QeOf1lPw.KQTtpbfJe1uHsq5WmAw1KTt mOrKLhLAgdMQGFdkK1H8hwefSQM7SMqVcryICgVWT5fUT85pkxxSFDckNuqs LCNFx6ylGOokFVBi_pDRmE5oKCVdZG_OWWMhsCBM7Z.qBHiHA1DS5awaidNe AKWtontoXCGsYPSW.hUcTSK7.YmleMrqxUaWDC_QpY5zTWxjDHgKVoJ7ITsX 5qBucRH1bhM31HLjy28a4dJINVwYYyQvz3M5kQgEsFBftk3XxniZDM9qt9xY mdeQmADdrBOGa_v0dKSLtUZOUyVs_uEa7bUiOSJPyWuKtL.T70LBAA7S_ikp bCH_rlcG0.dBBEVwLF4MjzCxjib9LMlSaddgoU8_K_B1L5sCWBldppt3l_7W sEGmgntTPcwPPxg34M8Bvr9a92.9DHXfnDnqXEfMeVyM8xR2vqYScPMpSAux bIcARh8wr1JZQSs.tXhy6Uwzs_yNhgpulOebLS.h6tmVSzkxEycnCJrinkG. BUMT5iFe92gWSdorXJITi4wxXYxPR1oH.D8PhWDg._2.2seA1o77C8EijlAi 31l8XX5pNdFyS22Dhr_rjloYLJ3qdzYJEhWGCo0YlUIignQC_dIFxpvhgwFs u19Fqj9Fbo637g01dlBe5.BtJP0IbpM7HZF44dokfmtKorWGVzUgLmRbFQtv YzCXjSze0DYetEqbQXCEleMovJfZ1jWUEOoYy0c65UsewR1BEAkkiAECbWga LSbMObCvPUYTtq9AQbu8uIgo3olN5AG87KIm1h0OMyEcBYzeB6VWcnlbHNKs 4NmmZknk2cQJ_vPFSg_lbKZkD.haKTBae.g1PwSMs04_gYPxoSxClYwZGPKX ZkxcDgXBBpggy2JHHYWjmhtMdqBDCVg.GOegiKPNuynZiAnJdelmGDvdbzFb 0kauiSwftUftwuiZRAQXrHUCkcnfrHd.Loyh0dfGJpqbwKp.4hQWLIT6ENKH cLPCPqwwtnNCl3ZK7It82ra9tw6QOsKC4ERtDptsRDzfPj2LArcMHdjiUacT NzOHt36JamlzNgRiHQGqwaBGFyJmy7G5Xc6cJJg7_hL9bD2zt1.BJZ0ZsrgY tHt0gxbNPy.6w6rZc_xWA9toeFd6uZ48ROSLM.XtFrKm8gqYwf926mbZE_01 wTeNg9xEP_IpHn_y7lDom8HpPBtON02pbBtTKg4cwWrTMiFchPYM5meX_56a ZKfKk_7U6uRjg9.JANf.Sqj1qknVW8VUj7.Lq3rUZR1mQxUdlb3HJW2PqS7O i8_bK5W0jXoont4U_7Z_ukgRAb2xLTt1se0CvmNzNUe.6pY_HBhQjIix3YMp mLNWTHDVFm5TXvBAuR0PM2ksZ1mfLVXb3ZYXhkHsweAkpmRlP8B65BhA_b1I gsAdS74xFe5XhpFQMpIjBFnwXRnJriDG6qg7rW3HKtzliIuMlVhvjp4ovw--
Authentication-Results mta4004.groups.mail.ne1.yahoo.com from=gmail.com; domainkeys=neutral (no sig); from=gmail.com; dkim=pass (ok)
X-Received from 127.0.0.1 (EHLO mail-pf1-f172.google.com) (209.85.210.172) by mta4004.groups.mail.ne1.yahoo.com with SMTPS; Sat, 24 Nov 2018 22:35:34 +0000
X-Received by mail-pf1-f172.google.com with SMTP id c123so4101269pfb.0 for <[email protected]>; Sat, 24 Nov 2018 14:35:34 -0800 (PST)
X-Google-DKIM-Signature v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=1e100.net; s=20161025; h=x-gm-message-state:subject:to:references:from:openpgp:autocrypt :message-id:date:user-agent:mime-version:in-reply-to :content-language; bh=ZwFVQm0YkeAWho8yWJdvziY4GXGET6t4pIthxY0OfDo=; b=m+r18rNGHxJz/u9iUq12jGaT0i8NmRhnqGU77o7t60Fvz837SNjdEXLouH3VeuGPKS YAd/1b7sVwizk2W0G+I+ztyK6YcnpxuFro1uKwFkjAjtIy7ammSfh1ffPZyBTO02GltL UQT0Dgc4R55IWzG2TlGmjqo0Y5ddh9G0S4uD38K8lrVc4AMGekHBDjwVkQ3PGMAW9CKX Zb5td+ecnwS7zXMAr6Jqw0p5/ZOF60RpuKH1x8WJC/jfFuxKfA1N5gAbQX8TIRwtaLiT 1ywB0eeXitcBYQfraunF4vBwV16N5wZx4zDCIBaftVtGe2EkNKzuAhKPAf7jXdcB/ILj +OuA==
X-Gm-Message-State AGRZ1gJ3qMJfFItPTFsL/LkdA3C19VopJX90l7Wd0lyWnibBu/UXyp/z ihmYTA5vQgxu3zMGb/5OuAzkRhsK
X-Google-Smtp-Source AJdET5d56w3GamQcR42Xe5vvg16opqfTkpnfaXxQItrj+0Vtat0q3eWG9EN5Pnn8iFrUrEE9s2FprA==
X-Received by 2002:aa7:8354:: with SMTP id z20mr21335168pfm.81.1543098933269; Sat, 24 Nov 2018 14:35:33 -0800 (PST)
X-Original-Return-Path <[email protected]>
X-Received from [192.168.10.185] ([162.244.37.15]) by smtp.googlemail.com with ESMTPSA id 79sm57955574pge.66.2018.11.24.14.35.31 for <[email protected]> (version=TLS1_2 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256 bits=128/128); Sat, 24 Nov 2018 14:35:32 -0800 (PST)
To [email protected]
References <CAPYb0EFi74xVZ2jFd33Pz_c9_dQ75CPvQmox=cyCXmnV_gTYFw@mail.gmail.com>
Openpgp preference=signencrypt
Autocrypt [email protected]; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= xsFNBFqnHl4BEAC2D/ejqMx87dzt7D1mXRlsoyaj15ZgiSeEW8avDH7iRxWF/xagNJw/C1BI 8WT4FMRFhDS9wFmTwJUhT09W4Rq2PwjTtWcUSUeMu4m3hvh70Tw4du+bpMKMoG56uo1DHlD3 A0/HYsVArjsf3wsae2ukhz6HjQGqLnGvVCUoKSuEG8nEUS15yWZMyoTCrBtU5cko+3O9Cm+L 4vL/K7GSBgwzErrXJOEBFraYB97Hjw43VaWEJ3Xft8SElz53+rRhVw0FgTNU4pKD5tzdy4MT dV7+N0OayO+jiMscBFA4SCFXFQFHC4SzMIK8TqA+pK2P6AihipgtOdSzNTBzDcCXrK7p40vR is+5l9TBc4AIgQhm4hA5mR3d3Ym07FzDoXxiZmZPnaoTY6sNj9u7WiYcJcQ5v2KV11jLvoiU CCzkjQLKqAJ3sYtMDNWnB5eNOd4NjXOVnorEgDmXyN1iT5XmtMSFJp0CwjhYmC2Xbeo85hWE 4tR5SJKksYa9szYTFDoYQ9S3Q96vxl8t2Y6Sb79VZXNzvd5uvwzXEhTBZAWH8HX2zLKS61Cj PDxNTWOrsEuUCLEEcNarUF4qNZUQY0TWzsntve6Evt9ncwNSnCfaGHij0/PWxk17wIetu/63 yoZKIHQnsitgCtAzU/lovMwz5eFtPCK/snvxWYOivHvhe9t9NQARAQABzRlNaWNrIDxta2pl a3lsbEBnbWFpbC5jb20+wsGUBBMBCAA+FiEEp76joP5XM22PiDq+OSrR4ccf/XkFAlqnHl4C GyMFCQlmAYAFCwkIBwIGFQoJCAsCBBYCAwECHgECF4AACgkQOSrR4ccf/XnJ1w//ZLePZRYc Nb7JgGobebLoxGeJvsLK01huCqs4OQm58HGH7qCaH019uMAciX72eEytgtCJk4OlZQDnX8fS Wpbhue6dGL3DWS1dSxzFP0iSqoRw/Xzq0KU0eQmofZR+Wy+jGblC3qUfp4HcfvRwPHMdhQpP fjcp4IsrN0KlUTZ2MoXgFp4H4Ztz3pST8fjsuZGhk/Jyc7/miJJVbd9W11MuIaNQ4Pp9FAC9 d1EN9jEiQlNHkPgpyEPEoBxqOD595pg858j63Dd+UJ6wm2D4oRnAisOx7Ytka/veimgfal1u WhKk81KZg1NT4e68VjnP0CUVScIK75D65BuWJaPp1yEzLX+PX/2YHZvdsNzyRN7rV4JCj0AC 90DL1Xf+ZOc4WhGVBxKDi7xUQWdhLatWhynRDKUeTgE3iKoyO5rAUBdSnYIWezpks/+FHSe8 oJfCnb5bwhjuvh2IgWjI+9pbo2sygYaqIj8g6aCUBRtBKLtGZuBMDYQ0vS/y9CJ5Drc/S7oD EdZwedRKflLpLR5Wwx4lnKXprYj3LD6ktikKcJejvJ8fE0KcOz3WJ9ygeTXktkUuUAhoyzGn Ugur6mCNfIGLNXj4tQYYtGtQm1d2G/c3K1ULh3lAQ0yWKILo1LFxF4x6rAnDG88TNnB342He rkoDYY5o15emK/fxKY5k84jGFsfOwU0EWqceXgEQALaewIOOSsgVQDqiojZVknrBkThxZ+UF hDxT1QGl+NK3MhtZ00XME0p4yjkIs8jO6+zRBQDCJLMhYHtoA7gbUlH5RyVVJRqH/swmbbFZ XQr8P5B/tZwtUH9zDbgPjk8zKN6trCgKbVW0FXOyBzTeLgoOWYjLvyXCUot5o2TQu9Vb0xAE QIXp7Xgh3FnW7ZfQPA/BtyaCDpWqX6cFzHhWpF3YY4iUF0APjFvXwRXspH9vnNj+qx/oUb5I uIf18MmGQye9h6zqItOC9qzDRLsKU4OVH3Ghqiu+P+UqxB7k5Tl9MbVWo9UUy9GMTyom64f9 UKQlvZAGnadldYp9vlF6b+dFDQQatJ3k6Bf1h6Ha82xFfvMwPR0VWiO0apKWRTlcRtVTDoQ6 5NFjcORngpj8C82ooLJ7/beYYPHL/3ke3Fp3hXWD32E5MMCun1EEVn/5dGwnLqvfwGh7sa49 JZDhq3CsTzZrUBZOrN2+JPB8WBeEW8OqZnwWqx3AU94MKEjkQCaxBYhTVzgPBfrHYxlSOtVZ 0dEY4AugklDiwYbTSHrlnXLWUaLPy79ChU4jx36ZqYlcGcLPBmDPKlfglr3EWB45MGffspBE g1B3qBzWGbxOb2HuNK9EUcB26nv1jvwkwdeaX32HDxnFD390uwZo1fkUWli/08z7SCvDEl/g Q2dXABEBAAHCwXwEGAEIACYWIQSnvqOg/lczbY+IOr45KtHhxx/9eQUCWqceXgIbDAUJCWYB gAAKCRA5KtHhxx/9eSMsEACLNZSE9Jenpz5yg1o3mNNeXmI4p2YzTz8KHkJuwWtFIiuGZi7I fUQZZHrRVQ8tpkJnmGrt2Cbu6y764xpaKwUNC6Z9eC41NKq/OdtE/6XwEfDrr6fnxYvUCcwF O26HPG44KtdgyBCUMO9iKtyifTpByK6X5u2Vq/gVAyf2cTiHAitOyD1Y6pPyRzdQE3legOr9 K3OguAWFd4TZ9TmL2WTyr06CcFJCAlmcX65PhcIxaVjjDQphQnL5KopumuWoZfl67fEb4vsI 320ut2HfFN9GzRlA2VnEHV/A2pu9wtSF/65wGHYKYNIcZxw0Xs0m6UZcT62nQEStV5lrBwGY CM43dZTkR/Vd9BC2VFLxdVLijNqI7FwsMErWKYvBsUt2DLHhIwAkows08yNCy7HE9Kfzl9bx wjDZhQJ9IVbnEvVsgo+3z1uS7cEYfMArUfPgy/i1eh56q0hFSZH0U3JqUBGdsdbMN8NKW3LR ZkjIuKCSu30AnvxJQZ+jd7kRb5NDCObahww4ylNnkOKP9C3LceWgxTchJh551yRNnxaO3H9q fXXrCfi0Rg/ttL9XRMhx0xTO3oyLasQrE/l/PXN8fExlCHOjUJ9pBcJwSCQvHn9QlJ8GjuJl 9Zi9raYZNZZbbVCaDwxAbhhQ5Q2xfTxE2k7QzVHCJ5fabGJ8Dcm/3Eny1g==
Message-ID <[email protected]>
Date Sat, 24 Nov 2018 14:35:31 -0800
User-Agent Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.3; WOW64; rv:60.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/60.3.1
MIME-Version 1.0
In-Reply-To <CAPYb0EFi74xVZ2jFd33Pz_c9_dQ75CPvQmox=cyCXmnV_gTYFw@mail.gmail.com>
Content-Type multipart/alternative; boundary="------------7AE6B20A03FAB2E577E6C459"
Content-Language en-US
X-Originating-IP 10.218.140.75
Subject Re: [EVGRAY] Benefiting from the Evolution in Power Transistors or smoke saver
X-Yahoo-Group-Post member; u=367442549; y=uecdC-4M7WqPsxbt6iUcjVgrqTDqSzxiaJW1sw8uQZdZ6a4
X-Yahoo-Profile mkjekyll
From Mick <[email protected]>