Re: [EVGRAY] Re: ? using LNA for front end of PA

Database ID: 107409
2018-03-26T10:12:56-07:00

← View thread

Message-ID
In-Reply-To: <[email protected]>

Body

Ole,

Yes I understand this part about building according to these RF rules,
just wondering if the theory is correct or if I am missing something
from my topology.

Thanks for the links, I already bought one of these but before I found
it I was contemplating what I asked you.  I have no idea how they build
an amp that is so wideband, how they come up with the trace lengths to
satisfy VHF to Microwave other than most of it resides on a chip with a
much shorter wavelength than the chip process dimensions.  They still
have to connect to the output device through traces of a certain length,
so how do they choose the trace length besides as short as possible?

I am sure the capacitance of the PCB is also a factor that has to be
taken into account.  Can't just put a huge ground plane on one side like
we do in audio.


On 3/26/2018 3:53 AM, [email protected] [EVGRAY] wrote:
>  
>
> Hi Mick,
>
> At those frequencies the energy is very radiant. Everything has to be
> made according to RF rules and treated as transmission lines. Else the
> signal doesn't follow the signal path as planned. Any change in
> impedance reflects or splits the signal. Read Ivor Catt on this even
> though he explains it using digital signals. If attaching a current
> buffer everything has to match. I haven't worked on such high
> frequencies. If trying this at least know the theory behind it or have
> the measuring instruments for this frequency range.
>
> This site (http://nov79.com/amr/cont.htm) shows how to make a simple
> current amplifier by using matched bipolar transistors. The upper
> frequency is only limited by the upper frequency of the transistors.
> This can be 40MHz for an audio amplifier. This may cause oscillations
> at the max frequency if not done the correct way.
>
> What about a small 3W broadband power amplifier module:
> https://www.ebay.com/itm/1-1000MHz-3W-RF-Broadband-Power-Amplifier-Module-Radio-Transmission-FM-VHF-/183031453375
> It only goes to 1GHz.
>
> Google search for 'broadband power amplifier module':
> https://www.google.dk/search?source=hp&ei=c8G4Wuv0LIXbwALZxJTQDw&q=broadband+power+amplifier+module&oq=broadband+power+ampli&gs_l=psy-ab.3.2.0l2j0i22i30k1l8.1878.9748.0.22828.21.20.0.1.1.0.104.1822.18j2.20.0....0...1c.1.64.psy-ab..0.21.1820...46j0i46k1j0i10k1.0.jIuIG0_77XA
>
> Or search 'rf power amplifier module'
>
> Regards
> Ole
>
>
>
> ---In [email protected], <mkjekyll@...> wrote :
>
> Ole,
>
> What would be the negative issues trying to attach a FET current buffer
> to an LNA in order to make a few watt wideband RF amplifier?
>
> As I am an audio guy I am paralleling this to an audio amp seems simple
> a voltage gain stage and then a current gain or buffer stage.
>
> There are plenty of cheap LNA's that are very wideband like this 
> https://www.ebay.com/itm/New-1MHz-2GHz-64dB-Gain-LNA-RF-Broadband-Low-Noise-Amplifier-Module-HF-VHF-UHF/232103825103?hash=item360a774ecf:g:iCQAAOSwgu9ZZEBg
>

References

<[email protected]>
<[email protected]>

Headers

Return-Path <[email protected]>
X-Sender [email protected]
X-Apparently-To [email protected]
X-Received (qmail 7401 invoked by uid 102); 26 Mar 2018 17:13:03 -0000
X-Received from unknown (HELO mtaq5.grp.bf1.yahoo.com) (10.198.29.78) by m4.grp.bf1.yahoo.com with SMTP; 26 Mar 2018 17:13:03 -0000
X-Received (qmail 23986 invoked from network); 26 Mar 2018 17:13:03 -0000
X-Received from unknown (HELO mta1006.groups.mail.ne1.yahoo.com) (98.138.100.121) by mtaq5.grp.bf1.yahoo.com with SMTP; 26 Mar 2018 17:13:03 -0000
X-Original-Return-Path <[email protected]>
X-Received-SPF pass (domain of gmail.com designates 209.85.192.177 as permitted sender)
X-YMailISG Uhyg2vMWLDuZoJyHm3W12R9mzsDv8iDO_ebv7cjiSee7Dc.R Ki5zu2M4_OUEiNf8VYo5gp8zy4FULFgjw2mBuULu_YTlxPb.AgnDKLEEPHj4 MuENFiMaGFI4gt4liFN5NPr3u.ewZMspMGOUt.ygNIxlF7H19s8ThV4mbPGt V_OY2GRkBeMGOHnvXPeEVcQ1Mu1XnSXo_MrHRn0Q..0wxvKnHZ9p2K_kwMeN D1h3ETwt.Y80mCrjznsL0Par7xsCwKC2im1lZlrkrKAoT5thdrlLEq0dLjgd sil1_zeROy0xVS2PbKLuiEOQly3sEnKiqRxltnXq1J3vEUDml4WnpvxXVB6Q 6LjjoM9U5gID3Lsx5Tw52ZdjMNlRAv8lH8BQCBpFVGraZHZYdy_PPlH30qLh wZcloN5hl5C47oB81nuWucHsVcYl6dE05Em03SXwc5kCH_B6bRRoUT5go8x2 2bFsZmy7SNNCkWHDu.QABe3YahdSlgAcw7JbWg4Nb1ubCp_a3PfyCLp.kXQv PO18SXwSiLSXyr9z2bl0QEW7E_Lc0t0TbUrygqQld7NvCyHyn9sXRVbWVRUo oazov6t3LkMfTNyivNgu.15Sx0stRTmTnvdWxxmCG2LJcro2JRYwhDOXfBWK pla6Pw1wBOiJaKB3hjtd1Jigv3v6y63WPGh9ALBxG1SPuRDHQQhA8abz6f6e 8_kQo5Oi0.k4itld15utNKSi_79XHrKmJwakA8qINM6FQd8Hjqosdc8GmRzs iCEdGj0I9u3FDTOIOtmXMN6aMLBRLcEap7IM73ctgCazA7ed.2cgBKqSCeLQ SBvBMcKhAm2P41.aI29S0DND5uxuHsaJE42xkXiQ..o05NjbEMGMOqZlcbdY dLHHSrlJi8VQWUOGW6CeB99Ikm44aYhRFxsj.uUPL2w2E4V0bXrmilttApbO PxcGrCdMq5xP6w.bWK61lApSciZdCjckn0MKRoq1sANHjJ03VyVRpuquwrag 7LdKeZXRkUN5ZhF6isbL_tq0WJKZaTDN545NUt.w5ThAH8JyELexwL5d52QZ 39YWxkv9B9DYDxFxLXFjc2blpIbIvQbHFVZpYoulInXHeZSNHMg9_82WsVk. 4URJc3NyEHAbFwfBOrPGHbgmPbdYjAxaWvzHJXmO9sGQWPMLj5HIbfUvOJ1x vkCWUJNmdU2Z6QOFb.Uzs8IxSidVo6ByFWDFLwxGJMx4lB7TOBRq3en1.PhR gHZb3aLtI.bwHhitiReD2ti0Dd.YxcIlu6N_L8M_kRgTnqdPkO6K3uA2gCgH lItXNpJsHG0PWJD4VgaZ4te3iPdLQHx7c7Jq.jhyl8EF5C0xDqCcchBi5PaR HLiYjgoB.RSqwooSoaiqhx7JAhPAau3oT.qSrHzhqU0TqVfTVfG1n_tMi0tG EMkj6Vo25oMjhNnyAElHrtfL5iggLOTZ0thNfapNwtm7Whvz_bavuNRebqKm d1SCfhFBywBgTjK.0u2kJ5RIpxZ4Kqy3VTziQyT.oXraHrix.0i_h7clXDeB Npk48J2hhlFY7BV9_uKFAaJEGwtjoWLgigUOaRxo_U4Wfh.3ffjS0BpxOhJx zmyWaSkN7zcv
Authentication-Results mta1006.groups.mail.ne1.yahoo.com from=gmail.com; domainkeys=neutral (no sig); from=gmail.com; dkim=pass (ok)
X-Received from 127.0.0.1 (EHLO mail-pf0-f177.google.com) (209.85.192.177) by mta1006.groups.mail.ne1.yahoo.com with SMTPS; Mon, 26 Mar 2018 17:13:02 +0000
X-Received by mail-pf0-f177.google.com with SMTP id j2so7764198pff.10 for <[email protected]>; Mon, 26 Mar 2018 10:13:02 -0700 (PDT)
X-Google-DKIM-Signature v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=1e100.net; s=20161025; h=x-gm-message-state:subject:to:references:from:openpgp:autocrypt :message-id:date:user-agent:mime-version:in-reply-to :content-language; bh=5nSX0+CQBDjJHhBkVZAC8sg3elZLT2vm66QjnQ+Sd2I=; b=nwSMlvQY4wAhRKduT2+8vKPwDVDDN4XFM1vODkuDM2be1YRMrXQIfWZsp0WlXtvDBg gXgr9K4e6W4Gkbv0UIg3UTX6FOLawLqts2JzUo0SQW0Z6nKUPK5PyAV6D46XJBuqWuwP /kwuJ+KG1FRXvN05iyw7Dj3EySu0pH02iGx+OT/is9vMpd7wY2HTntAVf4GodHdiFwoT Tii8F4IxJHn1BZqUGbXewAc9s4m6Rvxc7GR1dY/4YF6v560QjmWzBkFD3oALoIswSCD6 KuQWWTiT5bspYyOsNuHymFOJBHX84UmvjoZMOhCjpo7K9IQJwBgcjJR1E/Lxtacq6ROS 1XTw==
X-Gm-Message-State AElRT7EDOeTtTMgw7N1LV4SLwH0Kun2M0D6uMU+WuxWHqvC/fA9zSOi8 Cnx8wy0BmRJ0OgxcPPDrFzp6Tw==
X-Google-Smtp-Source AG47ELt6Uj+TXWCobtUjKb0bgfBS4/3XcLaHGHLCHgkHCl6uiMgq2hTwnqhQOXsbNehfgHGvLvhBpg==
X-Received by 10.101.82.12 with SMTP id o12mr14616566pgp.126.1522084380595; Mon, 26 Mar 2018 10:13:00 -0700 (PDT)
X-Original-Return-Path <[email protected]>
X-Received from [192.168.10.115] ([162.244.36.76]) by smtp.googlemail.com with ESMTPSA id 5sm33722159pfh.133.2018.03.26.10.12.59 for <[email protected]> (version=TLS1_2 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256 bits=128/128); Mon, 26 Mar 2018 10:12:59 -0700 (PDT)
To [email protected]
References <[email protected]> <[email protected]>
Openpgp preference=signencrypt
Autocrypt [email protected]; keydata= xsFNBFqnHl4BEAC2D/ejqMx87dzt7D1mXRlsoyaj15ZgiSeEW8avDH7iRxWF/xagNJw/C1BI 8WT4FMRFhDS9wFmTwJUhT09W4Rq2PwjTtWcUSUeMu4m3hvh70Tw4du+bpMKMoG56uo1DHlD3 A0/HYsVArjsf3wsae2ukhz6HjQGqLnGvVCUoKSuEG8nEUS15yWZMyoTCrBtU5cko+3O9Cm+L 4vL/K7GSBgwzErrXJOEBFraYB97Hjw43VaWEJ3Xft8SElz53+rRhVw0FgTNU4pKD5tzdy4MT dV7+N0OayO+jiMscBFA4SCFXFQFHC4SzMIK8TqA+pK2P6AihipgtOdSzNTBzDcCXrK7p40vR is+5l9TBc4AIgQhm4hA5mR3d3Ym07FzDoXxiZmZPnaoTY6sNj9u7WiYcJcQ5v2KV11jLvoiU CCzkjQLKqAJ3sYtMDNWnB5eNOd4NjXOVnorEgDmXyN1iT5XmtMSFJp0CwjhYmC2Xbeo85hWE 4tR5SJKksYa9szYTFDoYQ9S3Q96vxl8t2Y6Sb79VZXNzvd5uvwzXEhTBZAWH8HX2zLKS61Cj PDxNTWOrsEuUCLEEcNarUF4qNZUQY0TWzsntve6Evt9ncwNSnCfaGHij0/PWxk17wIetu/63 yoZKIHQnsitgCtAzU/lovMwz5eFtPCK/snvxWYOivHvhe9t9NQARAQABzRlNaWNrIDxta2pl a3lsbEBnbWFpbC5jb20+wsGUBBMBCAA+FiEEp76joP5XM22PiDq+OSrR4ccf/XkFAlqnHl4C GyMFCQlmAYAFCwkIBwIGFQoJCAsCBBYCAwECHgECF4AACgkQOSrR4ccf/XnJ1w//ZLePZRYc Nb7JgGobebLoxGeJvsLK01huCqs4OQm58HGH7qCaH019uMAciX72eEytgtCJk4OlZQDnX8fS Wpbhue6dGL3DWS1dSxzFP0iSqoRw/Xzq0KU0eQmofZR+Wy+jGblC3qUfp4HcfvRwPHMdhQpP fjcp4IsrN0KlUTZ2MoXgFp4H4Ztz3pST8fjsuZGhk/Jyc7/miJJVbd9W11MuIaNQ4Pp9FAC9 d1EN9jEiQlNHkPgpyEPEoBxqOD595pg858j63Dd+UJ6wm2D4oRnAisOx7Ytka/veimgfal1u WhKk81KZg1NT4e68VjnP0CUVScIK75D65BuWJaPp1yEzLX+PX/2YHZvdsNzyRN7rV4JCj0AC 90DL1Xf+ZOc4WhGVBxKDi7xUQWdhLatWhynRDKUeTgE3iKoyO5rAUBdSnYIWezpks/+FHSe8 oJfCnb5bwhjuvh2IgWjI+9pbo2sygYaqIj8g6aCUBRtBKLtGZuBMDYQ0vS/y9CJ5Drc/S7oD EdZwedRKflLpLR5Wwx4lnKXprYj3LD6ktikKcJejvJ8fE0KcOz3WJ9ygeTXktkUuUAhoyzGn Ugur6mCNfIGLNXj4tQYYtGtQm1d2G/c3K1ULh3lAQ0yWKILo1LFxF4x6rAnDG88TNnB342He rkoDYY5o15emK/fxKY5k84jGFsfOwU0EWqceXgEQALaewIOOSsgVQDqiojZVknrBkThxZ+UF hDxT1QGl+NK3MhtZ00XME0p4yjkIs8jO6+zRBQDCJLMhYHtoA7gbUlH5RyVVJRqH/swmbbFZ XQr8P5B/tZwtUH9zDbgPjk8zKN6trCgKbVW0FXOyBzTeLgoOWYjLvyXCUot5o2TQu9Vb0xAE QIXp7Xgh3FnW7ZfQPA/BtyaCDpWqX6cFzHhWpF3YY4iUF0APjFvXwRXspH9vnNj+qx/oUb5I uIf18MmGQye9h6zqItOC9qzDRLsKU4OVH3Ghqiu+P+UqxB7k5Tl9MbVWo9UUy9GMTyom64f9 UKQlvZAGnadldYp9vlF6b+dFDQQatJ3k6Bf1h6Ha82xFfvMwPR0VWiO0apKWRTlcRtVTDoQ6 5NFjcORngpj8C82ooLJ7/beYYPHL/3ke3Fp3hXWD32E5MMCun1EEVn/5dGwnLqvfwGh7sa49 JZDhq3CsTzZrUBZOrN2+JPB8WBeEW8OqZnwWqx3AU94MKEjkQCaxBYhTVzgPBfrHYxlSOtVZ 0dEY4AugklDiwYbTSHrlnXLWUaLPy79ChU4jx36ZqYlcGcLPBmDPKlfglr3EWB45MGffspBE g1B3qBzWGbxOb2HuNK9EUcB26nv1jvwkwdeaX32HDxnFD390uwZo1fkUWli/08z7SCvDEl/g Q2dXABEBAAHCwXwEGAEIACYWIQSnvqOg/lczbY+IOr45KtHhxx/9eQUCWqceXgIbDAUJCWYB gAAKCRA5KtHhxx/9eSMsEACLNZSE9Jenpz5yg1o3mNNeXmI4p2YzTz8KHkJuwWtFIiuGZi7I fUQZZHrRVQ8tpkJnmGrt2Cbu6y764xpaKwUNC6Z9eC41NKq/OdtE/6XwEfDrr6fnxYvUCcwF O26HPG44KtdgyBCUMO9iKtyifTpByK6X5u2Vq/gVAyf2cTiHAitOyD1Y6pPyRzdQE3legOr9 K3OguAWFd4TZ9TmL2WTyr06CcFJCAlmcX65PhcIxaVjjDQphQnL5KopumuWoZfl67fEb4vsI 320ut2HfFN9GzRlA2VnEHV/A2pu9wtSF/65wGHYKYNIcZxw0Xs0m6UZcT62nQEStV5lrBwGY CM43dZTkR/Vd9BC2VFLxdVLijNqI7FwsMErWKYvBsUt2DLHhIwAkows08yNCy7HE9Kfzl9bx wjDZhQJ9IVbnEvVsgo+3z1uS7cEYfMArUfPgy/i1eh56q0hFSZH0U3JqUBGdsdbMN8NKW3LR ZkjIuKCSu30AnvxJQZ+jd7kRb5NDCObahww4ylNnkOKP9C3LceWgxTchJh551yRNnxaO3H9q fXXrCfi0Rg/ttL9XRMhx0xTO3oyLasQrE/l/PXN8fExlCHOjUJ9pBcJwSCQvHn9QlJ8GjuJl 9Zi9raYZNZZbbVCaDwxAbhhQ5Q2xfTxE2k7QzVHCJ5fabGJ8Dcm/3Eny1g==
Message-ID <[email protected]>
Date Mon, 26 Mar 2018 10:12:56 -0700
User-Agent Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.3; WOW64; rv:52.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/52.6.0
MIME-Version 1.0
In-Reply-To <[email protected]>
Content-Type multipart/alternative; boundary="------------25790A84E7DFCF6531379CF9"
Content-Language en-US
X-Originating-IP 98.138.100.121
Subject Re: [EVGRAY] Re: ? using LNA for front end of PA
X-Yahoo-Group-Post member; u=367442549; y=mkQNK-AvMPHePVs2flZUundVDe8fvEM_f6Xs5tHmNeJUytA
X-Yahoo-Profile mkjekyll
From Mick <[email protected]>