Fw: Physics: Why don’t photons have mass?

Database ID: 114318
2019-09-03T02:34:15+00:00
Norman Wootan <[email protected]>

← View thread

Message-ID
In-Reply-To: <6XhcRczrWjIFHqXgedg172jiddcnhSkjmR8Hjqbb4JwUzwW8xj8ehHjPEjIR9Dk5vcrXO9MUS-StusgY2sWF80xAYNp9ZFPkbCjhuPmpsy29PhAdYr-Ia1hn3kABRDnqCTKAJFGDBC4AAQIA@t2.msgid.quoramail.com>

Body

Sent from Yahoo Mail on Android 
 
   ----- Forwarded Message ----- From: "Quora Digest" <[email protected]> To: "[email protected]" <[email protected]> Cc:  Sent: Mon, Sep 2, 2019 at 20:13 Subject: Physics: Why don’t photons have mass?  @media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356background_inner{padding:0!important;background:#fff!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356container{padding:0 8px 16px!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356footer_container{border-top:1px solid #e2e2e2!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356AnnualThankYouEmail .yiv6148454356background_inner{padding:10px 0!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356polish_background_inner{padding:10px 0!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356polish_header_logo img.yiv6148454356header_logo_img{width:118px!important;min-height:40px!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356polish_header_title{font-size:16px!important;padding-top:0!important;padding-bottom:5px!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356polish_question_text{line-height:1.3!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356polish_story .yiv6148454356voters_list, #yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356polish_story .yiv6148454356user_link{line-height:1.5!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356polish_story .yiv6148454356truncated_q_text, #yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356polish_story .yiv6148454356qtext_para{line-height:1.5!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356polish_story .yiv6148454356content_header{padding:6px 0!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356EndOfYearLookbackEmail .yiv6148454356stat_large{font-size:28px!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356EndOfYearLookbackEmail .yiv6148454356content_text{text-align:center!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356EndOfYearLookbackEmail .yiv6148454356half_column{width:100%!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356EndOfYearLookbackEmail .yiv6148454356img_wrapper{margin:10px auto!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356TopicDigestEmail .yiv6148454356topic_digest_header_logo img.yiv6148454356polish_header_logo_img{width:89px!important;min-height:30px!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356TopicDigestEmail .yiv6148454356topic_digest_header_title{font-size:16px!important;padding-top:0!important;padding-bottom:5px!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356WriteDigestEmail .yiv6148454356question_text .yiv6148454356rendered_qtext{font-size:16px!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356email_app_link-content{display:block!important;text-align:center!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356email_app_link-text, #yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356email_app_link-badges_wrapper{display:block!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356email_app_link-text{padding-bottom:0!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356email_app_link-badges_wrapper{padding-left:10px!important;}}@media screen and (max-width:600px){#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356DigestEmail .yiv6148454356mobile_image.yiv6148454356digest_ad{display:table!important;}#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356DigestEmail .yiv6148454356desktop_image.yiv6148454356digest_ad{display:none!important;}}
| 
| 
| Answer: First out, a photon is a packet of light.​ Well actually a packet of el.​.​.​
|  |
| Nichol's Digest |

 |
| 
| 
| 
| Top Stories For You |


| 
| 
|  |  |

 |
| Physics: Why don’t photons have mass? |
| 
| 
|   | 
| Mark John Fernee, 20+ years as a physicist |
| Written Jun 25 |

 |

 |
| 
First out, a photon is a packet of light. Well actually a packet of electromagnetic radiation if you're pedantic. You can have x-rays, gamma rays, UV rays, infrared rays, m...
 Read More » |

 |

 |


|  |  |  |


| 
| 
|  |  |

 |
| Could one nuclear engineer make a nuclear weapon all by himself? |
| 
| 
|   | 
| Mark Laris, I am a Nuclear Engineer with over 35 years experience. |
| Written Nov 16, 2016 |

 |

 |
| 
Unlike all the others who have answered this question, I actually am a Nuclear Engineer. Building a nuclear bomb is no longer a physics problem and any nuclear engineer wil...
 Read More » |

 |

 |


|  |  |  |


|  |  |  |


| 
| 
|  |  |

 |
| What is the strongest acid existing? |
| 
| 
|   | 
| James Harvey, MChem Chemistry, The University of York (2022) |
| Written Aug 28 |

 |

 |
| 
Fluoroantimonic acid is probably the best contender. It’s a superacid (any acid stronger than pure sulfuric acid is a superacid) made of [math]H^+ [/math]and [math]SbF_6^-[/math] which is made when you mix hyd...
 Read More » |

 |

 |


|  |  |  |


| 
| 
|  |  |

 |
| If I shine a flashlight at Mars, does a small amount of the light actually reach it? |
| 
| 
|   | 
| Bill Otto, former Boeing Technical Fellow Lasers & Electro-Optics (2001-2016) |
| Updated Jun 25 |

 |

 |
| 
Let's say you had a very nice flashlight with a 5 degree beamspread and a 1 watt visible beam.

At 60 million km to Mars at close approach, the beam spreads out over 2.5[math]\times[/math]10[math]^{13}[/math] sq km or 2.5[math]\times[/math]10[math]^{19}[/math]...
 Read More » |

 |

 |


|  |  |  |


| 
| 
|  |  |

 |
| Does Iran really need nuclear energy? |
| 
| 
|   | 
| Robert L Hill, worked at Capgemini |
| Written Jul 11 |

 |

 |
| 
I live in Dubai. My bedroom open up on the Straights of Hormuz. I can’t quite see Iran, because of the Earths curvature, and the desert haze, but close.

This region isn’t li...
 Read More » |

 |

 |


|  |  |  |


| 
| 
|  |  |

 |
| Why are you a Zionist? |
| 
| 
|   | 
| Moshe Zuchmir, lives in New York City (2008-present) |
| Updated Aug 26 |

 |

 |
| 
This is Batzion:

Unlike many other similar cases you'll hear these days, she actually grew up by loving and caring parents, and had her own home.

When she was about four year...
 Read More » |

 |

 |


|  |  |  |


| 
| 
|  |  |

 |
| Why is the speed of light so small relative to the size of the universe? |
| 
| 
|   | 
| Paul Ikeda, I have a deep interest in Physics, but I am not a physicist. |
| Updated Aug 21 |

 |

 |
| 
Great question though it’s funny you should ask it in the particular manner that you did. By that I mean ironic funny not lol funny.

But I get what you mean. The closest sta...
 Read More » |

 |

 |


|  |  |  |


| 
| 
|  |  |

 |
| If the Earth's gravity dropped 1% at noon tomorrow, what would be the first changes we'd notice? |
| 
| 
|   | 
| Dave Consiglio, Earth Science Teacher |
| Written Aug 22 |

 |

 |
| 
Everyone Dies™

1% doesn’t sound like much, and indeed it isn’t for things like walking around and breathing and whatnot. You’d hardly notice the reduction - your weight fluc...
 Read More » |

 |

 |


|  |  |  |


| 
| 
|  |  |

 |
| My brother believes in “Intelligent Design”. What is the best example you know of that actually shows “stupid design”? |
| 
| 
|   | 
| Ed Taboada, bacterial genomics, bioinformatics, food-borne pathogens, eater of tasty foods |
| Updated Fri |

 |

 |
| 
There are far too many to recount. But I will give you my favorite: the flounder’s eye.

From: The Mysterious Origin of the Wandering Eye (please read that blog, it’s chockfu...
 Read More » |

 |

 |


|  |  |  |


| 
| 
|  |  |

 |
| Has string theory been proven wrong? |
| 
| 
|   | 
| Toni Sementana, PhD Physics |
| Written May 21 |

 |

 |
| 
I would say yes, because the concept of extra dimensions appears to rest on shaky experimental foundations and with it those advanced physical theories that are based on it (...
 Read More » |

 |

 |

 |

 |   |

 |
| Read More in Your Feed |
| 
| Follow Quora on: |
| Get the App for iOS and Android |

 |

 |
| 
| This email was sent by Quora (650 Castro Street #450, Mountain View, CA 94041). If you don't want to receive this type of email in the future, please unsubscribe.http://www.quora.com/ |

 |

 |

@media (max-width:812px){#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356ad_email_background .yiv6148454356ad_table {margin:0;}}@media (max-width:812px){#yiv6148454356 .yiv6148454356ad_email_background .yiv6148454356ad_table {margin:0;}}

References

<6XhcRczrWjIFHqXgedg172jiddcnhSkjmR8Hjqbb4JwUzwW8xj8ehHjPEjIR9Dk5vcrXO9MUS-StusgY2sWF80xAYNp9ZFPkbCjhuPmpsy29PhAdYr-Ia1hn3kABRDnqCTKAJFGDBC4AAQIA@t2.msgid.quoramail.com>

Headers

Return-Path <[email protected]>
X-Sender [email protected]
X-Apparently-To [email protected]
X-Received (qmail 25286 invoked by uid 102); 3 Sep 2019 02:36:17 -0000
X-Received from unknown (HELO mtaq6.grp.bf1.yahoo.com) (10.198.29.79) by m3.grp.bf1.yahoo.com with SMTP; 3 Sep 2019 02:36:17 -0000
X-Received (qmail 18765 invoked from network); 3 Sep 2019 02:36:17 -0000
X-Received from unknown (HELO mta4000.groups.mail.bf1.yahoo.com) (10.201.194.145) by mtaq6.grp.bf1.yahoo.com with SMTP; 3 Sep 2019 02:36:17 -0000
X-Original-Return-Path <[email protected]>
Authentication-Results mta4000.groups.mail.bf1.yahoo.com; dkim=pass (ok) [email protected] header.s=s1024; spf=none [email protected]; dmarc=NULL(p=NULL sp=NULL dis=NULL) header.from=att.net;
X-Received-SPF none (domain of att.net does not designate permitted sender hosts)
X-YMailISG 4uBDdn8WLDstHQM84P.aCULJ4qo_lNQ5oGc.hvaqMMPzMp79 ZdnZWvNpiuuTilvb35U2lbrcyeN5A83_yZpPpKl8RSNSVV9uoZoclUiZi.Ib OUqACLsh7PiAP8q71EKVLiK.2WLn5GzYu.Pw_r6yfqschoH0kGmM8_eJ7DiZ wH8HSOgttduHd6PFYPuTVQpsWwYYHy660YR32dNeKQHJPtsZiXIeNkOAxhX. ZDi3tBwYM2YdCmFyscuF.TrGu3oiZeGnJ_zI2WaTY20Sbh07PP3WzVu7BY7B Ob5WI9LQbJfSBo10_zzxG.5N4StDRHXiX5.PoLN5OKRD8dE8NEzDHGJOrNvW _WW6xvK6fKHcNGwYVmO9lhuuVWNRU.EfYguZN6LOtVo7LffqL8zS1V5Hv8Y5 CXIp5iCT6tiuK.SQG7ApK9xlNmB.rUykpSweR9TWkI86K5FZWqoo01eaYKEC s5LESBZ85TXdhIO.v8g9w8Tp4ArcWJkdnQoKL2a2atJfAqXq2BgTY3cTSDoH 8ux_gFsufKKgYw_Uj2bkn5nQDks9E4T8206kFlNDRZR6WVIe0I787IIKiDV9 0xJbL7mySgSLvba6la6OcL.vd_cdoM9eOE78kLMBUQ5jcZNgxvKHOjYR1biF WsypbfUT8fdXfOL7uIGc6o3xZWTpj_tiqytJqCCEZA_EvCwI70goNYHjEfj_ KlW1N5vrQhZkdkuh4Ofz05YarFjvI5m0R5Ty909ciNrcrdOL92Tf114BaJYG yue8vO2xE5OFZgnFlDFLMkZfWqhBcxmcEIuDzJjaMeG6crPTHZlOxUo5S7lh 0Y_rMB2xbF_HviQlDvY79ALQl9_6HcbcCigyvk0mV9_2w6gjc6Qd3YUfBQwq t3LmvjKoAImjpzHtNrVA1NO8.TzSdRKg1Nmxtj5LWGW6vyeA_RwpfhRdcLwp jDUd4bJNnFzLanQcXpQfKYWRhLSgpXCD.7TwO9I5GvqMBqJ65m3igoWdvUSa MxGpH7rZMLTlloawakZbcvCrrQxTNZ50QvF5yDZIISdW4py4xXA_.u4.NX4H F_dwHgj5Y_zKSypu_5CF2XKtcz2LLUw8vzV1fcOOo2BuZ.8NQBLPGi3kTZ0K cH4TrHjAINMWhYBL5zp4PDNHqcTOZ2gQM3hN8YFJuP9dB7qneoomjJHfm8fN MNvWVsc-
X-Received from 127.0.0.1 (EHLO sonic312-52.consmr.mail.bf2.yahoo.com) (74.6.128.114) by mta4000.groups.mail.bf1.yahoo.com with SMTPS; Tue, 03 Sep 2019 02:36:17 +0000
X-YMail-OSG Y_p8DjwVM1nl6SMaQlYXSnW9bVprP0lVqDRwStiIU5JIzljMttYpm.O6tNLyc3_ JcJHpvprkavZOVmSZeImmDRpJj8deJghga71ITBppDXTm6DjkthVRglmdDEx13VkYgOSPUKz8BB6 9gadWsKjxaDQz7Vj5OhljYyF0Ns2nmHxIm_O2Ka1mOyBF3gi1132zj1GRANxwX8xoQHfbE4g2r3X pmITs6mxsnQfAGq.QNVzVavA0ikh39m.v59zIqVn29iO8B6HitCLe8uFkoE_1V2IpAJ_XS0UwNut sR4lX7fJKAU7qgl2ZUXxigjBiu6Lt47knX.qVkGkjA1VZly0OyVcPARV1Un92rGfOLIUl9xs3gf2 mkhF_9wT25r9H5W3Uw65OPdwUJF9h8Iznrc5EpNnkxOen3KzkPh4mfcMlWjZ1BtKqhfsTdRWW46O OdkL9mcBkKGUj_qbyUpNVkk_ZUF4y9NBrRzJ1fUGMvCGS3VYcoZve6iCHVuD40FIXD4oLvK3ccCt 4cJA6KGZjiuBULpHy_yXbaSDitnNbTnXnz8drsrEuVjyz2__YuivUkgdDIop65m8LNJuAtlJ2Oe6 Uthxwflk748PFq0DL1_8TcP3zp1N0KW9KW4S2unYCRzYTzyotxIEmJ9QtLsNYQWPEAW0wyYZ1Apw YhfwI9ECUs94vcXnifwCvrHNcYrl38pU0dT2wq.JIJUS6pErguWthMYl9qKZplmClSj1UGgBjNfW qbqDexesUcjElYTeqExHWtYGVTaXjmK7FO69pdjH7qzURQWJblFFNarJ7XKFjY5WFSA4Jsk10QCt W0P0Kf5.CFaunHAZlimyXXczUsRdTMC6w3V7.JGUkuBkrvcLRy_lg1dfJ2..h8bEPHyiIaN446Xd sFm.FY_tvWQnKfUM4bI07xvMeWZESudvKMiCQjdynAnRlfQWvgwPb8..A0i8M7nZLMbFWa03JuUZ g8daPB0tDEWTLDxDYtVpCKqt8rIPsEmzpG6Ps.LsnYSVCjSKXDrH2F07bTWzfLlOd5Qs6dvgOWVr jSrWNdM21lbAJuIRIbFPsPxpCq2oUlW8PZKhT4DyBiKSoY4PSBvVB8Gb0J51aEmySrnCCXCJOflb HEr5VA4s.2DW15KxUkok44HLSNuNuYf1_xAECxO.NANIAv7WNoiOHIj3DfsaU6WU3.j1_H6ph6y7 QupAcGPvsB13HFYF04sI8DRwnda8ZuEoe3aMRk._3QMqQZ0k2Tf_erL4OYBzjjJ44iVlsRHN0V.5 aE9iVUCzrgK8vEwbnw3ybk6C5cLbGH8mlZB105FXs__cNkpM32.CVT_6cqR6jrEw1KZR9rgO.viG SLX5wQpkm2dOsxW3Gj8j4F2KFpnFmtLGIXV_oq6_FQEfRJw--
X-Received from sonic.gate.mail.ne1.yahoo.com by sonic312.consmr.mail.bf2.yahoo.com with HTTP; Tue, 3 Sep 2019 02:36:17 +0000
Date Tue, 03 Sep 2019 02:34:15 +0000
To EVGRAY YahooGroups <[email protected]>, Mbking42 <[email protected]>, Bert Pool <[email protected]>, Bob Paddock <[email protected]>, Toby Grotz <[email protected]>, Phil Rembold <[email protected]>, Angel Alvarez <[email protected]>, Fredric Fletcher <[email protected]>, Walt <[email protected]>, Jeane Manning <[email protected]>, Jon Gentry <[email protected]>
Message-ID <[email protected]>
In-Reply-To <6XhcRczrWjIFHqXgedg172jiddcnhSkjmR8Hjqbb4JwUzwW8xj8ehHjPEjIR9Dk5vcrXO9MUS-StusgY2sWF80xAYNp9ZFPkbCjhuPmpsy29PhAdYr-Ia1hn3kABRDnqCTKAJFGDBC4AAQIA@t2.msgid.quoramail.com>
References <6XhcRczrWjIFHqXgedg172jiddcnhSkjmR8Hjqbb4JwUzwW8xj8ehHjPEjIR9Dk5vcrXO9MUS-StusgY2sWF80xAYNp9ZFPkbCjhuPmpsy29PhAdYr-Ia1hn3kABRDnqCTKAJFGDBC4AAQIA@t2.msgid.quoramail.com>
MIME-Version 1.0
Content-Type multipart/alternative; boundary="----=_Part_960878_1564533418.1567478055227"
X-Mailer WebService/1.1.14303 YahooMailAndroidMobile YMobile/1.0 (com.yahoo.mobile.client.android.mail/5.43.4; Android/9; PPR1.180610.011; dream2qltesq; samsung; SM-G955U; 5.94; 2076x1080;)
Content-Length 131276
X-Originating-IP 10.201.194.145
Reply-To "[email protected]" <[email protected]>
Subject Fw: Physics: Why don’t photons have mass?
X-Yahoo-Group-Post member; u=554418533; y=hnxi6W5-TVD-DUi8RkGhVyiBadcSYTRhoKkyPbHHvdbNsBnGTv0HUchv
X-Yahoo-Profile [email protected]
From Norman Wootan <[email protected]>