Re: [EVGRAY] Re: Moonbounce

Database ID: 108318
2018-06-06T15:49:22-07:00

← View thread

Message-ID
In-Reply-To: <[email protected]>

Body

Ole,

Specifically the math is messing with my head.  Either I am
misunderstanding / applying the math else according to FPL calculations
antenna gain and dbW something the distance of the moon should not be
feasible without millions of watts of transmitter power.

Laserbounce is another story due to the reflectors and the fact a laser
stays colimated enough not to disperse as quickly as does Rf.


On 6/6/2018 3:04 PM, [email protected] [EVGRAY] wrote:
>  
>
> Hi Mick,
>
> The problem by using the moon as a reflector could be made more
> efficient if placing a RF reflector just like the LASER reflectors
> already out there. Another way could be making a RF repeater like is
> done in communication satellites. It would probably be much cheaper to
> put up a communication satellite or to use one of the many already up
> there.
>
> The surface of the moon isn't a good conductor (I guess) and it may
> even spread out the signal instead of reflecting it back to the
> transmitter like it is done withcorner reflectors
> <https://wiki2.org/en/Corner_reflector>. This gives great loss of the
> received signal.
>
> Regards
> Ole
>
>
>
> ---In [email protected], <mkjekyll@...> wrote :
>
> https://www.electronics-notes.com/articles/ham_radio/amateur-propagation/moonbounce-propagation-eme.php
>
> Here is a link for ham radio folk about EME or moonbounce radio.  The
> path loss in best case scenarios is very high.
>
>
> Can someone who knows more RF electronics theory such as Ole or Hector
> please comment as to how this is overcome with 1000 watt input
> transmitter when the maximum theoretical S/N ratio and 252 db PL
> should require transmitters larger than AM radio stations.
>
>
> I must be missing something.  Also checking the amateur radio sites
> for an answer.
>
>
>
> Thanks,
>
> Mick
>
>
>
>

References

<[email protected]>
<[email protected]>

Headers

Return-Path <[email protected]>
X-Sender [email protected]
X-Apparently-To [email protected]
X-Received (qmail 15831 invoked by uid 102); 6 Jun 2018 22:49:28 -0000
X-Received from unknown (HELO mtaq6.grp.bf1.yahoo.com) (10.198.29.79) by m11.grp.bf1.yahoo.com with SMTP; 6 Jun 2018 22:49:28 -0000
X-Received (qmail 7779 invoked from network); 6 Jun 2018 22:49:28 -0000
X-Received from unknown (HELO mta4000.groups.mail.ne1.yahoo.com) (10.222.143.200) by mtaq6.grp.bf1.yahoo.com with SMTP; 6 Jun 2018 22:49:28 -0000
X-Original-Return-Path <[email protected]>
X-Received-SPF pass (domain of gmail.com designates 209.85.192.171 as permitted sender)
X-YMailISG i63vGxcWLDuvC0Y1os6h3gwn8I0OvPeyAlqghC41sGwP8lCQ hrWtzonAzY4cfe1hMt9xZaWyTolbyoQvii4lyEnRXVo.WaUMrAoVPL7QR08D OoA_yuo_9Ue0VOWz39eaESbJbgAA.iJ4tS.0nhtVMikZCOr1hWl_zv6p3XMs H.ej4BK1SHCnmjPyDpw3.yYDEP5wZhGTTdzEuqCSMN6NgybDGMnEiTlQJlmz u5bqbcp3xHUc.2o88D2d03_UqP42BRu_XL4IWQhDyw_y83_lfdEt05fZQVJd sK1pOcPiip8pl6jE6ICrK.h9O41k3KZHVYcPAn8osn.z1tb7xfMDqBDG8uZ4 Y_7D.p_Q34pVVI4cyS_MbYIn6DlfOnlgElrKVv3P3i1v0po9UwkDIR_fS8ki 1wpfDODDCy1ieeXJPbTxBoVju7OeOvSWKuDfDKF1Hd695Ni2.nv4Ge8Ru4YW G_r5mA9kK080jBDOoV9w1J_qhcUB1IlkcyxdEYnDZJ0.QtH5OWIjIzTjTH3Q bPUfro16J7s7AM9FDOE7G8yQcAP1aaSlukoQ4102sPnmD0_MJh_Kwda_YHBp BZ.KzGeZe0ShB3t5KuKwrNJw3bw0ddcMWuA4JzHCWJAA_IdWyaB6cHgXsH2W LPh1ODbYpnbQVC8u.ULw4ZFWPZkycxKADMOB8mCNBJv44slXywLPT_HscFA. 4jVEr8pABUBvvJe7rw.UBcapVDXoPQSQ8q6N_Pz2YSjxG7BPUwhai5U.xixi xNbz2mwm_QBbCfVXFPH4bJL2rarC.nKFo4eqZnvcUphWo_yOsSy7bzaJEHss Jzl6LQF3QylV2fi2zOeYm8uSdkT9Cv5.rNbfm54j3njIeT5DA7ZG.MMd5zkQ eagOSJk7rLLqolZOJSbQR397vi_0UgLH3ZoLyyzDES6WglhTli8MuQwCvq6. gS5mGULTJHN2lsNH.k6CXgwHRWTgdE22TF7i.RZSFgKNt5Rpz774IPA2qsDJ h5R0djTQ2aQJW48pQroacyC4b_51BUR4R58J21E93KJ7rP5fu0kkl5jTdxqN atr1qFr_wjeBbn6iMRE4NwXzTyk5J1buNbSHgD3xIsT77GUDBwthc9acKnc9 mJON7iXmEtK6gS7ftwIaeDkiWyE_fXZx1WJioWfq_KnypqYe4C0VYvGmZ0Qa 1nB0C1S1a544Pwao6E4qwVv6ACMqQ_5scQ_mLoiEsd4apS4FgYqsDVt7jOad av0NTWroY.EtldRwc8Wu1VSrbyPx6g_LPAaUSq_HqSewlP.PxOwJUKu_1L6Z EfIq5t4HK06F4GUlo0EV8ZBeasplAFGi4ZipzuG7YYZvwfK4Kxw_PZjTEvbA 3yVdWWUeMJap.xT0WnypGr1lo3Khsa.cddFacHeqy4BqpyUHasx1btHFJ3mG YZB6t13ZRzaUwAWH7SxWD21npfSvVh05L._U98iLZ4g_kjx_Lv.E6HmV4Tow 2KSuFNNofkjG3iDfM2tkpYqZzgSYpDC3nWZ2zJGnqtdpo.LF2qtMGDiH4AGR 4S_k
Authentication-Results mta4000.groups.mail.ne1.yahoo.com from=gmail.com; domainkeys=neutral (no sig); from=gmail.com; dkim=pass (ok)
X-Received from 127.0.0.1 (EHLO mail-pf0-f171.google.com) (209.85.192.171) by mta4000.groups.mail.ne1.yahoo.com with SMTPS; Wed, 06 Jun 2018 22:49:28 +0000
X-Received by mail-pf0-f171.google.com with SMTP id a12-v6so3858348pfi.3 for <[email protected]>; Wed, 06 Jun 2018 15:49:28 -0700 (PDT)
X-Google-DKIM-Signature v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=1e100.net; s=20161025; h=x-gm-message-state:subject:to:references:from:openpgp:autocrypt :message-id:date:user-agent:mime-version:in-reply-to :content-language; bh=Axa/4rj7goDwfhrccGnwk5erTjnG11Zl67boSN6IkL4=; b=BAaQxtWMTif8pQfLQ000AIv6pnyC8ijZMy3iLZSTnWAkf5N7zcI7HtbFpQef2OdqpF XIMX2+syAEkHsLdJP7arK2Mcs2/VNy6oUFJ0n+Qw0VlqpHIVrHRuqrOy6ba/eBQZkPlt xExIW4e1awPxglWOaSQ4YzfOkWbFz4qw5i+it6ujLgYdn6LLPWu+0RQWBmXqnc4Nj321 uoQKG0lK59FzvN65LUANBlx/GqVnYYo8cVTcN4jC2he/sVJPIpJpNa8eQxUI3eK3Mp48 RTV3eumNTIy+r7e4eV+hkkNy0rwjUBRe04Z3x6/MbQX8Hb8YfV4KN/FLHA3WdwJNt6pA 2i+Q==
X-Gm-Message-State APt69E00rKPCreTptW0tWudtVwhL6q50504pGnk9i19jfNCFfUaik0NY fn0P8tbwkn0M9JhQPvq1yTbr2A==
X-Google-Smtp-Source ADUXVKJ9O5jgTtfra4XuKoHNWP4F1lDwAqVlmJhkM7Vkt2VqURwFX5nyurugxm65UBCVpAsEF6muXA==
X-Received by 2002:a62:20c7:: with SMTP id m68-v6mr4154239pfj.110.1528325367431; Wed, 06 Jun 2018 15:49:27 -0700 (PDT)
X-Original-Return-Path <[email protected]>
X-Received from [192.168.10.185] ([162.244.37.186]) by smtp.googlemail.com with ESMTPSA id q9-v6sm18258128pgv.84.2018.06.06.15.49.26 for <[email protected]> (version=TLS1_2 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256 bits=128/128); Wed, 06 Jun 2018 15:49:27 -0700 (PDT)
To [email protected]
References <[email protected]> <[email protected]>
Openpgp preference=signencrypt
Autocrypt [email protected]; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= xsFNBFqnHl4BEAC2D/ejqMx87dzt7D1mXRlsoyaj15ZgiSeEW8avDH7iRxWF/xagNJw/C1BI 8WT4FMRFhDS9wFmTwJUhT09W4Rq2PwjTtWcUSUeMu4m3hvh70Tw4du+bpMKMoG56uo1DHlD3 A0/HYsVArjsf3wsae2ukhz6HjQGqLnGvVCUoKSuEG8nEUS15yWZMyoTCrBtU5cko+3O9Cm+L 4vL/K7GSBgwzErrXJOEBFraYB97Hjw43VaWEJ3Xft8SElz53+rRhVw0FgTNU4pKD5tzdy4MT dV7+N0OayO+jiMscBFA4SCFXFQFHC4SzMIK8TqA+pK2P6AihipgtOdSzNTBzDcCXrK7p40vR is+5l9TBc4AIgQhm4hA5mR3d3Ym07FzDoXxiZmZPnaoTY6sNj9u7WiYcJcQ5v2KV11jLvoiU CCzkjQLKqAJ3sYtMDNWnB5eNOd4NjXOVnorEgDmXyN1iT5XmtMSFJp0CwjhYmC2Xbeo85hWE 4tR5SJKksYa9szYTFDoYQ9S3Q96vxl8t2Y6Sb79VZXNzvd5uvwzXEhTBZAWH8HX2zLKS61Cj PDxNTWOrsEuUCLEEcNarUF4qNZUQY0TWzsntve6Evt9ncwNSnCfaGHij0/PWxk17wIetu/63 yoZKIHQnsitgCtAzU/lovMwz5eFtPCK/snvxWYOivHvhe9t9NQARAQABzRlNaWNrIDxta2pl a3lsbEBnbWFpbC5jb20+wsGUBBMBCAA+FiEEp76joP5XM22PiDq+OSrR4ccf/XkFAlqnHl4C GyMFCQlmAYAFCwkIBwIGFQoJCAsCBBYCAwECHgECF4AACgkQOSrR4ccf/XnJ1w//ZLePZRYc Nb7JgGobebLoxGeJvsLK01huCqs4OQm58HGH7qCaH019uMAciX72eEytgtCJk4OlZQDnX8fS Wpbhue6dGL3DWS1dSxzFP0iSqoRw/Xzq0KU0eQmofZR+Wy+jGblC3qUfp4HcfvRwPHMdhQpP fjcp4IsrN0KlUTZ2MoXgFp4H4Ztz3pST8fjsuZGhk/Jyc7/miJJVbd9W11MuIaNQ4Pp9FAC9 d1EN9jEiQlNHkPgpyEPEoBxqOD595pg858j63Dd+UJ6wm2D4oRnAisOx7Ytka/veimgfal1u WhKk81KZg1NT4e68VjnP0CUVScIK75D65BuWJaPp1yEzLX+PX/2YHZvdsNzyRN7rV4JCj0AC 90DL1Xf+ZOc4WhGVBxKDi7xUQWdhLatWhynRDKUeTgE3iKoyO5rAUBdSnYIWezpks/+FHSe8 oJfCnb5bwhjuvh2IgWjI+9pbo2sygYaqIj8g6aCUBRtBKLtGZuBMDYQ0vS/y9CJ5Drc/S7oD EdZwedRKflLpLR5Wwx4lnKXprYj3LD6ktikKcJejvJ8fE0KcOz3WJ9ygeTXktkUuUAhoyzGn Ugur6mCNfIGLNXj4tQYYtGtQm1d2G/c3K1ULh3lAQ0yWKILo1LFxF4x6rAnDG88TNnB342He rkoDYY5o15emK/fxKY5k84jGFsfOwU0EWqceXgEQALaewIOOSsgVQDqiojZVknrBkThxZ+UF hDxT1QGl+NK3MhtZ00XME0p4yjkIs8jO6+zRBQDCJLMhYHtoA7gbUlH5RyVVJRqH/swmbbFZ XQr8P5B/tZwtUH9zDbgPjk8zKN6trCgKbVW0FXOyBzTeLgoOWYjLvyXCUot5o2TQu9Vb0xAE QIXp7Xgh3FnW7ZfQPA/BtyaCDpWqX6cFzHhWpF3YY4iUF0APjFvXwRXspH9vnNj+qx/oUb5I uIf18MmGQye9h6zqItOC9qzDRLsKU4OVH3Ghqiu+P+UqxB7k5Tl9MbVWo9UUy9GMTyom64f9 UKQlvZAGnadldYp9vlF6b+dFDQQatJ3k6Bf1h6Ha82xFfvMwPR0VWiO0apKWRTlcRtVTDoQ6 5NFjcORngpj8C82ooLJ7/beYYPHL/3ke3Fp3hXWD32E5MMCun1EEVn/5dGwnLqvfwGh7sa49 JZDhq3CsTzZrUBZOrN2+JPB8WBeEW8OqZnwWqx3AU94MKEjkQCaxBYhTVzgPBfrHYxlSOtVZ 0dEY4AugklDiwYbTSHrlnXLWUaLPy79ChU4jx36ZqYlcGcLPBmDPKlfglr3EWB45MGffspBE g1B3qBzWGbxOb2HuNK9EUcB26nv1jvwkwdeaX32HDxnFD390uwZo1fkUWli/08z7SCvDEl/g Q2dXABEBAAHCwXwEGAEIACYWIQSnvqOg/lczbY+IOr45KtHhxx/9eQUCWqceXgIbDAUJCWYB gAAKCRA5KtHhxx/9eSMsEACLNZSE9Jenpz5yg1o3mNNeXmI4p2YzTz8KHkJuwWtFIiuGZi7I fUQZZHrRVQ8tpkJnmGrt2Cbu6y764xpaKwUNC6Z9eC41NKq/OdtE/6XwEfDrr6fnxYvUCcwF O26HPG44KtdgyBCUMO9iKtyifTpByK6X5u2Vq/gVAyf2cTiHAitOyD1Y6pPyRzdQE3legOr9 K3OguAWFd4TZ9TmL2WTyr06CcFJCAlmcX65PhcIxaVjjDQphQnL5KopumuWoZfl67fEb4vsI 320ut2HfFN9GzRlA2VnEHV/A2pu9wtSF/65wGHYKYNIcZxw0Xs0m6UZcT62nQEStV5lrBwGY CM43dZTkR/Vd9BC2VFLxdVLijNqI7FwsMErWKYvBsUt2DLHhIwAkows08yNCy7HE9Kfzl9bx wjDZhQJ9IVbnEvVsgo+3z1uS7cEYfMArUfPgy/i1eh56q0hFSZH0U3JqUBGdsdbMN8NKW3LR ZkjIuKCSu30AnvxJQZ+jd7kRb5NDCObahww4ylNnkOKP9C3LceWgxTchJh551yRNnxaO3H9q fXXrCfi0Rg/ttL9XRMhx0xTO3oyLasQrE/l/PXN8fExlCHOjUJ9pBcJwSCQvHn9QlJ8GjuJl 9Zi9raYZNZZbbVCaDwxAbhhQ5Q2xfTxE2k7QzVHCJ5fabGJ8Dcm/3Eny1g==
Message-ID <[email protected]>
Date Wed, 06 Jun 2018 15:49:22 -0700
User-Agent Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.3; WOW64; rv:52.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/52.8.0
MIME-Version 1.0
In-Reply-To <[email protected]>
Content-Type multipart/alternative; boundary="------------7637DF7DDF717C10CC677E40"
Content-Language en-US
X-Originating-IP 10.222.143.200
Subject Re: [EVGRAY] Re: Moonbounce
X-Yahoo-Group-Post member; u=367442549; y=_0iEUAhQWwePdYztKC-3nk5qaSJq8nCHDM-MCJUw-K-rAOA
X-Yahoo-Profile mkjekyll
From Mick <[email protected]>